Education at the Crossroad:  Carceral and Racial Intersections in the Lives of Women and Girls

Education, Gender Equity

Education at the Crossroad:  Carceral and Racial Intersections in the Lives of Women and Girls

Vivian Nixon, Ph.D.
A look at the historical causes and consequences of the American Criminal Legal System related to the intersection of gender, race, and education
Print All

Description

Explicit and implicit biases contribute to inequity and significant achievement gaps in education. Research has shown a connection between success in early childhood education and imprisonment. Education is equitable when outcomes are similar for all students regardless of race, gender, ethnicity, class, language, ability, or sexual orientation. Unfortunately, America’s system of public education has become less equitable despite attempts to achieve equity through various means, including integration and privatization. This has contributed to a disparate number of Black women entering America’s criminal legal systems where education is rarely available and typically undervalued. America remains the world’s largest jailer and women are proportionately the fastest growing population in its prisons. This course examines factors that create women’s pathways into the criminal legal system and how higher education might intervene at any point along the continuum. How does interaction with the criminal justice system shape the future quality of life for women with previously poor educational outcomes? What educational interventions are effective in criminal justice settings? What core practices lead to these women’s success in educational programs, particularly college? What short and long-term outcomes are achieved when such opportunities are available?

This course reviews the historical causes and consequences of the American Criminal Legal System related to the intersection of gender, race, and education.

Topics/ Learning Objectives

This is a seminar. While there will be brief talks and viewing of films or film clips, much of the seminar will be a dialogue between students and instructors. It is essential that you come to class prepared to engage in conversation. 

Your interest in your classmates’ thoughts and ideas is appreciated in a seminar. All opinions are valid. There are no silly questions. There are no right or wrong answers—unless we discuss hardcore facts. There is no such thing as a wrong opinion. We can disagree respectfully. It is of utmost importance that we honor one another’s humanity and respect that there may be topics discussed to which some have extreme sensitivity.

Required Material

Becoming Ms. Burton: From Prison to Recovery to Leading the Fight for Incarcerated Women by Susan Burton
Find on Bookshop, Online, or your local library

Pushout: The Criminalization of Black Girls in Schools by Monique Morris
Find on Bookshop, Online, or your local library

Suggested Material

Changing Minds: The Effect of College in Prison in a Maximum-Security Prison by Michelle Fine, Maria Elena Torre, Kathy Boudin, Iris Bowen, Judith Clarke, Donna Hylton, Migdalia Martinez, “Missy”, Rosemarie A. Roberts, Pamela Smart, Debora Upegui
Find Online or at your local library
2015 AERA Distinguished Lecture College in Prison: A Cause in Need of Advocacy and Research by Ellen Condliffe Lagemann
Find Online, or your local library
The Politics and Paradox of Teaching Higher Education in Women’s Prisons by Breea Chaunte Willingham May
Find Online or at your local library
Education in Prison and the Self-Stigma: Empowerment Continuum by Douglas N. Evans, Emily Pelletier, and Jason Szkola
Find Online or your local library
College in Prison: Reading in an Age of Mass Incarceration by Daniel Karpowitz
Find on Bookshop, Online, or your local library
Beyond Recidivism by Emily Pelletier
Find on Bookshop, Online, or your local library

Schedule and Assignments

Readings:

Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 1-2

Pushout Chapters 1-2

  1. Class introductions
  2. Syllabus Review
  3. Discussion of Pushout Film
  4. Discussion of readings
  5. Wrap – up go over next week’s assignments 5 Minutes 

Turn in reflection paper on film Pushout

Readings: 

  1. Changing Minds. Collaborative Research by The Graduate Center of the City University of New York & Women in Prison at the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility Michelle Fine, Maria Elena Torre, Kathy Boudin, Iris Bowen, Judith Clark, Donna Hylton, Migdalia Martinez, “Missy”, Rosemarie A. Roberts, Pamela Smart, Debora Upegui with a Reincarceration Analysis conducted by The New York State Department of Correctional Services. September 2001.
  2. Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 3-8
  3. Pushout Chapters 3-4 (If you have not already, please read Intro and forward)

Video:

  1. Ellen Condliffe Lagemann. 2015 AERA Distinguished Lecture College in Prison: A Cause in Need of Advocacy and Research 

Readings:

  1. The politics and Paradox of Teaching Higher Education in Women’s Prisons by Breea Chaunte Willingham May 2014
  2. Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 9-13
  3. Pushout Chapters 5 and Epilogue

Turn in reflection paper on Changing Minds

Video:

  1. College Behind Bars, Part 1

Readings:

  1. Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 14-18
  2. Pushout Chapters Appendix A, Appendix B and Methodology
Video:
  1. College Behind Bars, Part 2

Readings:
  1. Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 19-24
  2. Reading:  Prison Higher Education and Social Transformation.  Jody Lewen SOCIAL INEQUALITY AND THE U.S. PRISON SYSTEM
  3. New York Women’s Foundation Report Rikers
  4. New York Women’s Foundation Report Adult Women
Video:
  1. College Behind Bars, Part 3

Reading:
  1. Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 25-30
  2. Reading:  Education in Prison and the Self-Stigma: Empowerment Continuum. Douglas N. Evans, Emily Pelletier, and Jason Szkola
  3. Essie Justice Report:  Because She’s Powerful
Video:
  1. College Behind Bars, Part 4

Reading:
  1. Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 31-35
  2. Reading:   Daniel Karpowitz.; College in Prison : Reading in an Age of Mass Incarceration. Chapter 1. Getting In. Conflicting Voices and the Politics of College in Prison

Turn in reflection paper on College Behind Bars


Readings:
  1. Beyond Recidivism Author(s): Emily Pelletier and Douglas Evans. Source: Journal of Correctional Education (1974-) , Vol. 70, No. 2 (August 2019), pp. 49-68. Published by: Correctional Education Association 
  2. Becoming Ms. Burton Chapters 36-39
  3. Johns Hopkins University Press. W.E.B. DuBois The Non-Market Benefits of Higher Education
  4. Homegrown Social Capital

Turn in reflection paper on Becoming Ms. Burton

Group Discussion:

Share what you wrote about.

Turn in Final reflection paper:  Topic of choice from the entire seminar.

Should anyone be incarcerated for life is a question our nation must grapple with.  In fact, we are grappling with whether prisons should exist at all.  However, for now, prisons do exist.  So, if we have prisons, why, or why not, should we educate people in them?  Does education have specific benefits for women, women of color, why?  These are sample questions to consider as you search for a topic.

Expectations and Assessments

Students will be successful if they complete the required reading, attend each course session, and take part in class discussions. 

One Reflection paper of 2-3 pages is due each week, beginning with the second session. Each reflection paper must be based on the combined readings for the meeting but should not be a retelling of the readings. The paper should reflect your thoughts after integrating the readings.  When writing your reflections, consider current events, your prior perceptions about American Criminal Legal Systems, or a new line of thinking you are developing based on the readings. The reflection must represent your thinking and not merely a summarized repetition of the readings.